Initial Benchmarking of the Quality of Medical Care in Childhood-Onset Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

Mina, R.; Harris, J. G.; Klein-Gitelman, M. S.; Appenzeller, S.; Centeville, M.; Eskra, D.; Huggins, J. L.; Johnson, A. L.; Khubchandani, R.; Khandekar, P.; Lee, J.; Liu, H. M.; Pendl, J. D.; Silva, C. A.; Silva, M. F.; Zaal, A. I.; DeWitt, E. M.; Ardoin, S. P.; Brunner, H. I.

Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2015 Jul 30; 68(2):179-86


OBJECTIVE: To assess the quality of medical care in childhood-onset systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) at tertiary pediatric rheumatology centers as measured by observance of SLE quality indicators (SLE-QIs). METHODS: International consensus has been achieved for childhood-onset SLE-QIs capturing medical care provision in 9 domains: diagnostic testing, education of cardiovascular (CV) risk and lifestyles, lupus nephritis (LN), medication management, bone health, ophthalmologic surveillance, transition, pregnancy, and vaccination. Using medical record information, the level of performance of these childhood-onset SLE-QIs was assessed in childhood-onset SLE populations treated at 4 tertiary pediatric rheumatology centers in the US, 2 in Brazil, and 1 center in India. RESULTS: A total of 483 childhood-onset SLE patients were assessed. Care for the 310 US patients differed markedly for childhood-onset SLE-QIs addressing LN, bone health, vaccinations, education on CV risk, and transition planning. Performance of safety blood testing for medications was high at all centers. Despite often similar performance on the childhood-onset SLE-QI, access to kidney biopsies was lower in Brazil than in the US. Irrespective of the country of practice, larger centers tended to meet the childhood-onset SLE-QIs more often than smaller centers. CONCLUSION: The childhood-onset SLE-QIs, evidence-based minimum standards of medical care, are not consistently met in the US or some other countries outside the US. This has the potential to contribute to suboptimal childhood-onset SLE outcomes.

Read More on PubMed